| Baseball | |||
| 1959 | Brodie Baker | NAIA Honorable Mention Academic All-American | |
| 1960 | Brodie Baker | NAIA Honorable Mention Academic All-American | |
| 1966 | Jim Bryan | NAIA Second Team All-American | |
| 1966 | Sandy Gann | NAIA Honorable Mention Academic All-American | |
| 1966 | Tommy Grayson | NAIA Honorable Mention Academic All-American | |
| 1967 | Jim Bryan | NAIA Second Team All-American | |
| 1967 | Tommy Grayson | NAIA First Team All-American | |
| 1968 | Tommy Grayson | NAIA First Team All-American | |
| 2002 | Joe Dooley | ABCA Second Team All-American | |
| 2009 | Kyle Wooden | ABCA Second Team All-American | |
| 2009 | Kyle Wooden |
D3baseball.com Second Team All-American |
|
|
2011 |
Kyle Wooden | D3baseball.com Second Team All-American | |
| 2014 | John Macon Smith | ABCA Third Team All-American | |
| 2014 | John Macon Smith | Capital One/CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American | |
| Basketball | |||
| 1967 | Bob Kauffman | All-American | |
| 1968 | Bob Kauffman | Converse All-American | |
| 1968 | Bob Kauffman | AP All-American | |
| 1968 | Bob Kauffman | NAIA All-American | |
| 1968 | Bob Kauffman | National Association of Basketball Coaches All-American | |
| 1970 | David Smith | Second Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1971 | David Smith | NAIA All-American | |
| 1972 | Jerry Crocker | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1972 | M. L. Carr | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1973 | M. L. Carr | First team NAIA All-American | |
| 1973 | World B. Free | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1974 | World B. Free | Little All-American | |
| 1974 | World B. Free | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1975 | World B. Free | Little All-American | |
| 1975 | World B. Free | NAIA All-American | |
| 1976 | Sam Kennedy | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1977 | Sam Kennedy | Third Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1977 | Gary Devlin | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1978 | Gary Devlin | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1980 | Al King | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1982 | Sharon Parks | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1983 | Sharon Parks | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1984 | Lois Wright | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1984 | Chris Lambert | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1985 | Lois Wright | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1985 | Christopher Lambert | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1986 | Darryl Dozier | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1993 | Brenda Davis | NCAA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1994 | Brenda Davis | NCAA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1997 | Laura Haynes | NCAA Kodak /WBCA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1998 | Marija Preimats | Third Team GTE College Division Academic All-American | |
| 1998 | Laura Haynes | First Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2000 | Arden Miller | NCAA Kodak/WBCA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2007 | Ben Strong | NABC First Team All-American (Co-Player of the Year) | |
| 2007 | Ben Strong | D3hoops.com First Team All-American (Player of the Year) | |
| 2008 | Ben Strong | NABC First Team All-American | |
| 2009 | Tyler Sanborn | D3hoops.com Fourth Team All-American | |
| 2010 | Clay Henson | DIII News Third Team All-American | |
| 2010 | Tyler Sanborn | Basketball Times First Team All-American (Player of the Year) | |
| 2010 | Tyler Sanborn | NABC First Team All-American (Player of the Year) | |
| 2010 | Tyler Sanborn | DIII News First Team All-American (Player of the Year) | |
| 2015 | Matt McCarthy | NABC Second Team All-American | |
| 2016 | Anais Weatherly | WBCA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| Cross Country | |||
| 2013 | Chad Norton | U.S. Track & Field/Cross Country Coaches Association All-American | |
| Football | |||
| 1946 | Art Faircloth | Associated Press Little All-America Honorable Mention | |
| 1946 | Lody Glenn | Associated Press Little All-America Honorable Mention | |
| 1946 | John Henzel | Associated Press Little All-America Honorable Mention | |
| 1959 | John Meroney | First Team Little All-American | |
| 1960 | Wayne Henley | Third Team Little All-American | |
| 1961 | Walter Wiggins | Honorable Mention AP Little All-American | |
| 1965 | Ron Winslow | Second Team Little All-American | |
| 1967 | Bill Burchette | Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1967 | Henry McKay | AP All-American | |
| 1967 | Henry McKay | NAIA All-American | |
| 1970 | Geoff Clark | Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1974 | Steve Musulin | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1974 | Tony Swainey | NAIA All-American | |
| 1975 | Bunky James | Honorable Mention AP All-American | |
| 1975 | Steve Musulin | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1975 | Al Patterson | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1975 | Reggie Kenan | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1975 | Reggie Kenan | A.P. All-American | |
| 1975 | Steve Musulin | A.P. All-American | |
| 1976 | Bunky James | Third Team All-American | |
| 1976 | Reggie Kenan | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1980 | Bill Branson | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1983 | Pernell Jefferson | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1983 | Eric Scott | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1984 | Pernell Jefferson | First Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1985 | Alan Foley | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1986 | Alan Foley | Second Team NAIA All-American | |
| 1986 | Rob Aplington | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1987 | Daniel Cole | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1987 | Jeff Schreiber | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1987 | Wayne Shepherd | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1987 | Kamus McNair | NAIA All-American | |
| 1988 | Daniel Cole | NAIA All-American | |
| 1990 | Charles Rowe | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1991 | Rodney Alexander | NCAA All-American | |
| 1994 | Bryan Garland | American Football Coaches Association All-American | |
| 1995 | David Heggie | Football Gazette NCAA Division III All-American | |
| 1998 | Junior Lord | Honorable Mention Football Gazette All-American | |
| 1998 | Junior Lord | Third Team Hewlett Packard All-American | |
| 2001 | Chris McKinney | First Team Hewlett Packard All-American | |
| 2001 | Chris McKinney | First Team Football Gazette All-American | |
| 2001 | Chris McKinney | First Team D3football.com All-American | |
| 2003 | Christian Adams | Second Team College Sports Information Directors All-American | |
| 2004 | Christian Adams | Second Team Football Gazette All-American | |
| 2004 | Christian Adams | Third Team Team D3football.com All-American | |
| 2005 | Chris Barnette | Second Team Football Gazette All-American | |
| 2006 | Chris Barnette | First Team D3football.com All-American | |
| 2006 | Chris Barnette | Second Team Football Gazette All-American | |
| 2006 | Chris Barnette | American Football Coaches Association All-American | |
| 2006 | Mike Six | Honorable Mention Football Gazette All-American | |
| 2008 | Kevin Vaughn | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2013 | Satiir Stevenson | American Football Coaches Association All-American | |
| 2013 | Satiir Stevenson | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2014 | JerMario Gooch | D3football.com Second Team All-American | |
| 2014 | Satiir Stevenson | American Football Coaches Association All-American | |
| 2014 | Satiir Stevenson | D3football.com First Team All-American | |
| 2014 | Satiir Stevenson | AP Little All-American | |
| 2015 | De'Eric Bell | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2015 | Tyler Hunt | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2015 | Matt Pawlowski | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2015 | Adam Smith | D3football.com Third Team All-American | |
| 2017 | De'Eric Bell | American Football Coaches Association First Team All-American | |
| 2017 | De'Eric Bell | D3football.com First Team All-American | |
| 2017 | Vic Smith, Jr. |
D3football.com Third Team All-American |
|
| 2018 | De'Eric Bell |
American Football Coaches Association First Team All-American |
|
| 2018 | De'Eric Bell |
D3football.com Third Team All-American |
|
| 2019 | Jermaine Russell | D3football.com Honorable Mention All-American | |
| Golf | |||
| 1979 | Jay Kennedy | NAIA All-American | |
| 1979 | Robert Linville | NAIA All-American | |
| 1980 | Jay Kennedy | NAIA All-American | |
| 1982 | Bill Brooks | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1983 | Bill Brooks | NAIA All-American | |
| 1983 | Keith King | NAIA All-American | |
| 1985 | Steve Harwell | NAIA All American | |
| 1985 | Keith King | NAIA All-American | |
| 1986 | Mike Beaver | NAIA All-American | |
| 1986 | Rob Odom | NAIA All-American | |
| 1987 | Rob Odom | NAIA All-American | |
| 1987 | Lee Porter | NAIA All-American | |
| 1987 | Mike Beaver | NAIA All-American | |
| 1988 | Lee Porter | NAIA All-American | |
| 1988 | Mike Hutcheon | NAIA All-American | |
| 1988 | Lee Porter | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1989 | Michael Hutcheon | NAIA All-American | |
| 1989 | Chris Haarlow | NAIA All-American | |
| 1990 | Chris Haarlow | NAIA All-American | |
| 1990 | Mike Lefevers | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1991 | Chris Haarlow | NAIA All-American | |
| 1996 | Matt Saglio | NCAA All-America | |
| 1997 | Bo Reitz | Second Team NCAA All-American | |
| 1997 | Matt Saglio | NCAA All-American | |
| 1997 | Matt Caruso | GCAA Academic All-American | |
| 1998 | Bo Reitz | Second Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2000 | Andrew Biggadike | Third Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2000 | Andrew Eversole | Third Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2000 | Nathan Stambaugh | GCAA Academic All-American | |
| 2001 | Andrew Biggadike | First Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2001 | Clint Fields | GCAA Academic All-American | |
| 2001 | Dave Patterson | Second Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2001 | Savio Nazareth | Third Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2002 | Andrew Biggadike | Second Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2002 | Savio Nazareth | Third Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2002 | Dave Patterson | First Team NCAA All-American | |
| 2003 | Ricky Gandhi | Cleveland Golf All-America Scholar | |
| 2003 | Dave Patterson | PING Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2004 | Colin Clark | PING Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2005 | Colin Clark | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2005 | Dave Patterson | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2005 | Brant Stovall | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2006 | Chris Lowman | PING Third Team All-American | |
| 2006 | Jeff Osberg | PING Second Team All-American | |
| 2006 | Joseph Poplin | PING Second Team All-American | |
| 2007 | Joseph Poplin | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2009 | Brian Creghan | Cleveland Golf/Srixon All-America Scholar | |
| 2010 | Brian Creghan | Cleveland Golf/Srixon All-America Scholar | |
| 2010 | Brian Creghan | CoSIDA/ESPN The Magazine Second Team Academic All-American | |
| 2010 | Brian Creghan | PING Second Team All-American | |
| 2010 | Peter Latimer | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2010 | Dusty Roberts | PING Third Team All-American | |
| 2011 | Noah Ratner | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2012 | Noah Ratner | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2013 | Noah Ratner | PING First Team All-American | |
| 2013 | Drew Thompson | PING Third Team All-American | |
| 2014 | Tanner Gross | PING Second Team All-American | |
| 2015 | Ty Palmer | PING Third Team All-American | |
| 2015 | Drew Thompson | PING Third Team All-American | |
| 2017 | Josh Hill | PING Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2019 | Josh Hill | PING Second Team All-American | |
| 2019 | Addison Manring | PING Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2019 | James Mishoe | PING First Team All-American | |
| Lacrosse | |||
| 1982 | Bryan Savage | USILA All-American | |
| 1984 | Scott Nixon | USILA All-American | |
| 1985 | Tom Schoendorf | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1985 | Tim Diamond | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1986 | Joseph Savarese | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1986 | Anthony A. LoRicco | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1986 | Tim Diamond | USILA All-American | |
| 1987 | Chip Van Reenan | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1988 | John Burke | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1992 | Dave Brown | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1992 | Matt Parker | USILA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 2013 | E'leyna Garcia | Capital One/CoSIDA Second Team Academic All-American | |
| 2014 | E'leyna Garcia | Capital One/CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American | |
| 2014 | E'leyna Garcia | Intercollegiate Women's Lacrosse Coaches Association Third Team All-American | |
| Soccer | |||
| 1983 | David Hood | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1986 | Chris Jenkins | NAIA All-American | |
| 1990 | Amy Warner (Alfaro) | Third Team GTE/CoSIDA Academic All-American | |
| 2002 | Alexandra Hutton | Verizon/CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American | |
| 2003 | Tim Imafidon | Third Team National Soccer Coaches' Association of America/adidas All-American | |
| 2006 | Jennah Carter | Second Team National Soccer Coaches' Association of America/adidas All-American | |
| Softball | |||
| 2014 | Cynthia Hayes | First Team National Fastpitch Coaches Association All-American | |
| 2016 | Laura Hall | Second Team Division III CoSIDA Academic All-American | |
| 2018 | Makayla Carver | Third Team National Fastpitch Coaches Association All-American | |
| Tennis | |||
| 1980 | Bill Stephanz | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1981 | Shirley Dunn | NAIA All-American | |
| 1981 | Sue Ireton | NAIA All-American | |
| 1981 | Kerry Kennedy | NAIA All-American | |
| 1981 | Leesa Shapiro | NAIA All-American | |
| 1981 | Tammy Strickland | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1982 | Tarja Koho | NAIA All-American | |
| 1982 | Kerry Kennedy | NAIA-All American | |
| 1983 | Lili Carpenter | Academic All-American | |
| 1985 | Lisa Miller | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1985 | Julie Tupper | NAIA All American | |
| 1986 | Lisa Miller | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1986 | Julie Tupper | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1986 | Nick Demetriades | NAIA Honorable Mention All American | |
| 1986 | Matt Mason | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1987 | Rick Feit | NAIA All-American | |
| 1987 | Jochen Klinke | NAIA All-American | |
| 1987 | Matt Mason | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1988 | Jill Daly | NAIA All-American | |
| 1989 | Joanne Black | Academic All-American | |
| 1989 | Jill Daly | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1990 | Jill Daly | Volvo/NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1996 | Kevin Pendergrast | ITA Men's Division III All-American | |
| 1997 | Betsy Parker | Second Team NCAA Academic All-American | |
| Volleyball | |||
| 1981 | Terri Heath | NAIA Honorable Mention All-American | |
| 1981 | Sharon Parks | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1982 | Sharon Parks | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| 1990 | Laura Klingseisen | NAIA Academic All-American | |
| Outdoor Track | |||
| 2011 | Jonathan Smith | NCAA First Team All-American | |
| Indoor Track | |||
| 2012 | Jonathan Smith | NCAA First Team All-American |